top of page

Chickens came home to roost - again

Writer: Robert Scott
Robert Scott
Nov 4
3 min read

I have seen this movie before.


In 2006, I was working as press secretary for Republican gubernatorial candidate Ken Blackwell. I was on the inside of an Ohio political campaign ultimately suffered one of the most significant Republican defeats in modern state history. Nearly 20 years later, the results of the 2026 election look remarkably familiar.


For years, Republicans in Ohio enjoyed a political advantage believed difficult for Democrats to overcome. They controlled the governor's office, held commanding majorities in the Ohio General Assembly and benefited from a state Donald Trump carried comfortably in three presidential elections.


The parallels to 2006 are difficult to overlook. That year, Democrat Ted Strickland defeated Ken Blackwell 60.5% to 36.6%, ending 16 years of Republican control of the governor's office. Also, Democrats elected Sherrod Brown to the U.S. Senate, defeating incumbent Republican Mike DeWine. Republicans lost every statewide election except the State Auditor’s office. Sound familiar?


This year, Democrat Amy Acton defeated Republican Vivek Ramaswamy in the governor's race, becoming Ohio's first Democratic governor in 20 years and the first woman elected to the office. Sherrod Brown returned to the U.S. Senate after defeating Republican incumbent Jon Husted. Democrats also made gains in congressional and state legislative races, including the defeat of longtime Dayton-area Congressman Mike Turner.


In both elections, Republicans found themselves on the wrong side of a national political environment.


In 2006, President George W. Bush was deeply unpopular. The Iraq War, growing frustration with Washington and a series of Republican scandals had taken their toll. Republicans paid the price for the national administration. Bush's approval rating stood at just 38% shortly before Election Day.


In 2026, Republicans faced a similar challenge with President Donald Trump. His unpopularity and voter frustration with the direction of Washington became a political liability for candidates. Ohio Republicans found themselves carrying some of the baggage of the national administration, whether they agreed with every presidential decision or not.


I remember 2006 because I was there. I remember the campaign, the challenges and the difficult reality of watching a statewide Republican operation come up short. There were plenty of explanations offered afterward, but one lesson was unmistakable: A political party cannot ignore the environment in which it is operating and expect voters to separate every candidate from the party in power.


In Montgomery County, Democrats demonstrated their political strength. Acton carried the county with 57%. Brown performed well, Democrats won county commission and auditor races, several statehouse seats and judgeships.


The results are particularly important in the Dayton area, where Republicans have historically relied on strong support throughout surrounding suburban and rural communities, but turnout lagged in those areas.


Republicans still have considerable support in Butler, Greene, Miami, Preble, Warren and other traditionally Republican counties, but Democrats cut the margins in those counties. Statewide losses demonstrate those advantages cannot be taken for granted. Even longtime Republican strongholds are not immune to changing political attitudes.


So what happened?


First, there is the issue of affordability. Families continue to feel pressure from gas prices, housing costs, groceries, insurance, utilities and everyday expenses. Republicans spent considerable time talking about economic growth, tax policy and national political victories. Voters ultimately care about basic pocketbook issues and whether those policies are improving their own financial circumstances.


Second, Republicans cannot ignore the consequences of governing. Holding majorities in Columbus comes with responsibility and accountability.


For several years, Ohio Republicans have had considerable control over state government. They had the opportunity to advance their priorities, but voters had plenty of time to evaluate their decisions.


Property taxes, school funding, spending priorities, education policy and the relationship between state government and local communities have all generated debate.


Third, the Republican Party needs to examine its messaging and its relationship with voters.


National politics increasingly dominates political conversations, sometimes at the expense of issues of Ohio communities. Local candidates have little control over decisions made in Washington, but face voters frustrated with the national party.


I learned some of these lessons firsthand in 2006. Republicans eventually recovered, won back the governor's office in 2010 and rebuilt their statewide political advantage. The party had to regroup, reassess and reconnect with voters.


I watched the chickens come home to roost in 2006. I am watching it happen again in 2026.


Rob Scott is the Kettering Clerk of Court, an attorney and a small-business owner. Contact him at rob@robscott.us.

Comments


bottom of page